Product comparison
Supergoop! Mattescreen SPF 40 vs Black Girl Sunscreen Make It Matte SPF 45
Two options for the same routine step. Compare recorded facts and historical discussions, with the evidence limits kept visible. These separate samples do not establish a winner or individual suitability.
What to compare
- Why consider it
- Consider another sunscreen option listing avobenzone with three other organic filters; inspect the separate finish discussions rather than assuming the name predicts wear.
- What stays similar
- Both occupy the sunscreen step; label SPF, regional formula and instructions must be checked separately.
- What changes
- Supergoop! Mattescreen SPF 40: The current Mattescreen brand page lists titanium dioxide and zinc oxide plus dimethicone; the page has multiple tint options, so the historical analyzed variant is not confirmed as equivalent. Black Girl Sunscreen Make It Matte SPF 45: The BGS brand page lists avobenzone, homosalate, octisalate and octocrylene as active filters.
Historical review discussion
Each product has its own sample. Counts describe coded discussions, not efficacy, safety, risk or a head-to-head test. Positive and negative directions are shown together; mixed, neutral and unknown directions remain separate. Topic counts can overlap and must not be added as people.
Finish / oil / shine
Supergoop! Mattescreen SPF 40
Preliminary493 of 620 analyzed discussions mention this topic.
Positive455 / 493
Negative16 / 493
Mixed4 / 493
Neutral18 / 493
Unknown0 / 493
No mention: 118. Mention uncertain: 9. Direction denominators above include only the 493 topic mentions.
Black Girl Sunscreen Make It Matte SPF 45
214 of 243 analyzed discussions mention this topic.
Positive130 / 214
Negative66 / 214
Mixed11 / 214
Neutral7 / 214
Unknown0 / 214
No mention: 27. Mention uncertain: 2. Direction denominators above include only the 214 topic mentions.
Pilling
Supergoop! Mattescreen SPF 40
42 of 620 analyzed discussions mention this topic.
Positive21 / 42
Negative19 / 42
Mixed0 / 42
Neutral2 / 42
Unknown0 / 42
No mention: 576. Mention uncertain: 2. Direction denominators above include only the 42 topic mentions.
Black Girl Sunscreen Make It Matte SPF 45
13 of 243 analyzed discussions mention this topic.
Positive4 / 13
Negative9 / 13
Mixed0 / 13
Neutral0 / 13
Unknown0 / 13
Small topic sample (n < 30): counts only.
No mention: 230. Mention uncertain: 0. Direction denominators above include only the 13 topic mentions.
White cast
Supergoop! Mattescreen SPF 40
96 of 620 analyzed discussions mention this topic.
Positive70 / 96
Negative15 / 96
Mixed5 / 96
Neutral6 / 96
Unknown0 / 96
No mention: 517. Mention uncertain: 7. Direction denominators above include only the 96 topic mentions.
Black Girl Sunscreen Make It Matte SPF 45
60 of 243 analyzed discussions mention this topic.
Positive49 / 60
Negative0 / 60
Mixed0 / 60
Neutral11 / 60
Unknown0 / 60
No mention: 183. Mention uncertain: 0. Direction denominators above include only the 60 topic mentions.
How to read this comparison
- Supergoop! Mattescreen SPF 40 — Historical targeted recall enriched for explicit oily/combination self-reports; separate from the main sample and not population prevalence. Analysis version: A5-v7-sol.
- Black Girl Sunscreen Make It Matte SPF 45 — Historical targeted recall enriched for explicit oily/combination self-reports; separate from the main sample and not population prevalence. Analysis version: A5-v7-sol.
Preliminary marks a topic kappa from 0.60 to just under 0.80. Topics below 0.60, or without an applicable numeric kappa, are withheld. We use the lowest applicable numeric topic kappa; undefined constant-label metrics are not treated as perfect scores. Model agreement does not establish independent accuracy.
Only counts are shown. For fewer than 30 topic mentions, the sample is too small for a reliable proportion. We have not recoded or expanded the historical samples for this page.
Price not compared. No pair of validated offers with the same explicitly bound capacity and unit was available. Check current price, availability, package and regional formula with the merchant.
Check the current label before choosing a product. Historical reviews do not confirm current formula equivalence. Consumer experiences are not medical advice.
Sources and information gaps
- Supergoop! Mattescreen SPF 40 brand page (supergoop.com). Record date: 2026-10-19. Selected ingredient / format facts from the saved brand page. Current formula equivalence to the historical review sample is not established.
- Black Girl Sunscreen Make It Matte SPF 45 brand page (blackgirlsunscreen.com). Record date: 2026-10-19. Brand facts read in the saved browser capture; direct GET was blocked (403). Current formula equivalence to the historical review sample is not established.
Source records refer to the saved checks dated above; they are not a new live check. Review quotations are not reproduced. Read our review method.
Choose another comparison